Ok, I’ve looked at the pics and I’m not following how the new indicator switch is better.
Do a Pauline Hanson….
Well, I've now gone for a ride on my R18 with it, and I am not sure how the new indicator switch is better either (for me).
I can see how it might be better if you have a "wheel" between the grip and the switch cluster (ie thumb reach).... but I don't have that on either bike.
HOWEVER, I've not formed a "view" as of this moment.... as I am too analytical to be so frivolous as to post an "early finding"..... sometimes a new thumb action can take some time to become "better normal"..... so will give it 5 or so rides and see where it lands.
Whatever happens I've only invested the equivalent of a slab of "Coopers Stout" (none of that crappy fake stout for me.... ie 21st century Guinnes.....
might as well be drinking Fosters and thinking it's good beer)
Now to do a Pauline (ie please explain?).... remember you asked for this...... the indicator button is much like the "toe/heel" lever(s)...... first off one has to state clearly ones "user requirement "..... so.....
Toe/Heel UR:
user 1: (me) size 10 shoe, doesn't ride in heavy boots, doesn't want to lift foot off board, just pivot off ball or heel to change up or down or up gears (quick'n slick), up change always via heel shift (no foot under front lever to shift up), like quick smooth shits for fast riding
user 2: rides in heavy boots, use to lifting leg to shift, cruising riding mostly
user 3: feels better toe shifting, occasional heel shifting, size 12 boots.....
etc etc.... I could do 6 to 8 or so of these.... all would end up with differently placed shift levers, extensions etc to optimise the R18 experience for that user.... some might not even find a good setup is possible.
User 4 to infinity and beyond....
now to the "indicator switch"
User A: wants to not have to semi rotate left hand around grip/thumb wheel to reach indicater switch (TC and Bagger etc)
User B (me): finds normal switch a bit fiddly.... could be better maybe? No wheel in the way though. Minor issue really...
User C: etc
anyway, I'm B and thought I'd gamble a carton on it.... (only because I don't have to go without a carton to gamble a carton......)