I'm against making the R18 Harley. That's why I have other leather and cotton canvas bags, but never anything like this. But I'm not criticizing. Something different for everyone
I am not criticizing either, but you are missing the point (your market) entirely. Think of the R18 as exactly that - a German 'Harley'; BMW taking on Harley in Harley's own backyard, playing the ballgame that Harley invented. BMW will only win a small part of that market. We, the ones vocalizing our opinions here, represent that small part.
Also, appreciate
Form and Function. Your products, e.g. solo rack and panniers, are practical and efficient (all Function) but do not even remotely complement the aesthetics, stride and pose of the R18 (zero Form). They might well fit in on a R1250GS, but not on an S1000RR and most definitely not on the R18.
With the possible exception of Black Dog, none of us here bought the R18 for how effective or how much of an all-rounder it is. I do not think that I have read even a single overly positive Motorcycle Review on it - well, scr3w those journos, influencers, et al. For some of us, myself included, this is the first BMW motorcycle or even BMW product that we have purchased - and mostly because of what it
looks like and how much better, even, we perceive it could
look like with our individual personal preferences implemented. In some respects, we are still only formalizing those preferences, which is why we hang out here.
The R18 is All Form - whatever we buy to fit on it needs to function well, of course, but the overriding consideration is what it
looks like and how well it fits in with the rest of the bike. And with the emphasis on 'Retro' and what earlier Beemer pot-scrapers looked like.