• Welcome to the BMW R18 Forums. Member registration disables ads and allows you to post and share. Register Here.

Search results

  1. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    I have gotten caught in the rain on some road trips, and I accept that for what it is. Riding in the rain isn't my favorite type of riding. If I plan a couple of hours of riding and it rains, I'll reschedule.
  2. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    I think you make a great point, if you don't ride in the wet, and I would bet there are a significant number of members here who don't, it's probably not much of a failure risk.
  3. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    Obviously, this situation is not great for the trade or resale value for current owners, but is a good situation for people in the market. I recently saw a 2022 R18 b with less than 3k miles for $12,000. You'd pay around $22k for a similar Road Glide. Getting a break on the buy in price takes...
  4. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    If there is any positive to this, it has created a substantial negotiation lever for purchasing a new bike, especially since there is not resolution date and it happened right on the back to the headlight recall.
  5. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    BMW is no stranger to price gouging. They wanted almost $5k to replace the timing chain on my 3 series. I was researching prices on spare parts, and on several things I checked, BMW averaged about 5x the price for similar parts compared to Harley.
  6. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    Definitely is a separate motor.
  7. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    I don't see how this is unclear. The input shaft and the counter shaft have to be disconnected mechanically from the output shaft during reverse operation. BMW does not want the engine to be turned backwards, cracking a compression or oil ring. That is why the bike must be in neutral. The...
  8. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    Hopefully I didn't come across as argumentative, I don't have a dog in the fight one way or the other. My point was only to actually understand what is going on with the system. From what I see in the drawing, the bike must be in neutral, as neutral regarding the connection of the main drive...
  9. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    So clearly, if this drawing is accurate, there is a reverse gear.
  10. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    https://www.r18forums.com/threads/issue-with-the-reverse-gear.323/#:~:text=On my latest ride, I thought I’d try to reverse Reading through this thread, are a lot of comments about moving or rocking the bike to get the reverse lever out of the reverse position. If you have to move or rock the...
  11. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    I'm not sure I'm buying that regarding the R18 considering you can physically feel it engage when you turn the lever. Also, what other reason would you need the lever if the button were just going to spin the starter motor in reverse?
  12. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    The lever for reverse is definitely engaging a reverse gear. If it feels bound up, it probably needs the bike to rolled slightly to reposition the gears in the transmission. This is not completely uncommon of a manual transmission car. It occasionally happens on my 6 speed WRX. I don't think...
  13. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    Reverse on the K1600 is engaged by pushing a button on the left side controls. Then you use the starter to back the bike up. I would guess that it uses the same electronics, but the engagement is different. Since the K1600 doesn't have a lever to engage the reverse gear, it shouldn't have any...
  14. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    I know they have had multiple electrical issues on the 2024 Road and Street Glides. The new infotainment systems is really good on those bikes, but they don't seem to have the bugs worked out yet. I know of two different guys that had to have complete new wiring harnesses installed due to issues.
  15. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    Got a call from the dealer today. They let me know that they can now sell me an R18 as long as I sign a document accepting that the reverse will be disabled until the recall fix can be implemented. The description I got today of the error condition is that the seal around the reverse selector...
  16. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    I confess I don't know how it works outside of the United States, but BMW cannot void your warranty here if you do your own service on the bike, unless they can prove you made an unauthorized modification or was negligent in the performance of the service, such as leaving a drain plug loose...
  17. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    At least here in the US, they are on the hook for a ton of warranty, product liability, and personal injury claims should the worst case occur. No doubt they know this, hence the stop sell. Their liability exposure may be less in other countries, but it is significant here. I'm sure they are...
  18. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    I'm not sure how it works in Australia, but why do you have to let BMW deactivate the reverse. Here in the US, you could just not take your bike into the dealership. There's no mechanism to force you to comply with the recall here.
  19. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    Having been an engineer at two different German companies, I can definitively say that German equipment manufacturers, including the car/motorcycle companies don't like to admit when they've gotten something wrong. That typically turns into extended times for them to get design fixes...
  20. MN246

    Recall? On all models with Reverse

    I think this recall is a real problem for BMW. For one, the idea that they are going to sell people a bike with an option that adds value, and then disable that option, even if its for a safety issue, is likely to be a violation of consumer protection laws. I think they will ultimately have to...
Back
Top